When I’m developing Worktile Pro with ES6 and ES7, arrow function is one of features I like most. This makes me to use arrow function as anywhere as I could. But I also encountered some problem by using it. For example, in one my previous post, I found arguments are not defined in arrow function. Several days ago I found another problem about this in arrow function.

Let’s have a look on the sample code below. Here I have a module exports two method, one was defined in arrow function, the other was in traditional function.

// arrow-fn-and-this.js
'use strict';

exports.arrowFn = () => {
    console.log(this && this.name);

exports.normalFn = function () {
    console.log(this && this.name);

Below is how I was using it.

// app.js
'use strict';

const fns = require('./arrow-fn-and-this.js');

const that = {
    name: 'Shaun Xu'

const bindArrowFn = fns.arrowFn.bind(that);
const bindNormalFn = fns.normalFn.bind(that);


As you can see I bind these two function with that variable. What we will get when I executed app.js?


The method defined in traditional way worked as we expected, but the arrow function worked strange. this variable inside the arrow function was undefined even though I bind to that. Why?

The reason is, different from traditional function, this in an arrow function is NOT a variable. In MDN document, this arrow function is lexical. What that mean is, when we define an arrow function, this value will be assigned based on where the arrow function was defined, rather than what it will be assigned later when the application was running. this in arrow function works more like a constant, rather than a variable. The value of a constant was being decided based on the code, rather than the runtime assignment.

Update 2016-06-12

Thanks to nelsonlaquet who pointed me the example below is NOT correct. I created a gist as better example and please refer the comments below.

The code below partially explained what this works in an arrow function.

const wrapper = {
    fn: () => {
        // `this` was defined as the enclosing context, which is `wrapper`, as a constant
        const this = wrapper;
        // ... some codes else

fn = () => {
    // since there's no enclosing context, `this` would be `undefined`
    const this = undefined;
    // ... some codes

But in traditional function, this is just a variable which can be assigned in runtime. It works like this.

const wrapper = {
    fn: function () {
        var this = retrieve_this_magically(thisArg);
        // ... some codes else using `this`

When invoking function through object.method approach, retrieve_this_magically will be the object and assigned to this. When using Function.prototype.bind, Function.prototype.apply and Function.prototype.call, it will assign this based the first parameter of bind, apply and call.~~

So to be summary, arrow function is great and it reduce the complexity of our code. But when using arrow function, pay attention to its lexical variables:

  • arguments
  • super
  • this
  • new.target They are defined and assigned based on the code, and cannot be changed in runtime.

Hope this helps, Shaun